Ex-Premier League referee Mark Halsey believes that center-back Gabriel Magalhaes was incredibly lucky to avoid being dismissed following the head-to-head clash with Erling Haaland. This specialist noted that Haaland's decision not to simulate a fall "rescued" the Brazilian defender from a heavy sanction.
The "early final" of the season between Manchester City and Arsenal at Etihad unfolded as anticipated, delivering high drama.
The peak of tension occurred in the 83rd minute. After a forceful collision, Haaland, in a rage, shoved Arsenal's center-back Gabriel. Gabriel immediately retaliated by stepping close, face-to-face, and making a headbutting motion toward the Norwegian striker. However, referee Anthony Taylor only issued yellow cards to both players.
Analyzing this incident on SunSport, former referee Mark Halsey suggested Gabriel owes Haaland a thank you: "Both displayed aggressive attitudes, but Gabriel clearly moved his head toward Haaland. If Haaland had fallen and exaggerated, Gabriel would certainly have received a red card for violent conduct and faced a three-match suspension. Haaland staying upright made the situation appear less severe to the referee."
Aligning with Halsey's view, Erling Haaland himself admitted after the match to Sky Sports: "If I had gone down, it probably would have been a red card. But I would never do that unless genuinely attacked. I don't understand why I got a yellow card, but football is like that."

Haaland commended for 'fair play' during Arsenal defender's headbutt.
The Premier League organizing body later issued an official statement, confirming that VAR had reviewed and agreed with the on-field referee's decision because Gabriel's action "did not reach the level of excessive aggression or violence" warranting a direct red card.
The spotlight match wasn't limited to that single incident. Earlier, Haaland surprised spectators by having to change his shirt on the pitch after Gabriel tore the sleeve during a challenge. Additionally, referee Anthony Taylor received support from expert Halsey regarding two other sensitive situations.
Regarding Gabriel's handball incident in the penalty area, Halsey affirmed the ball touched his hand above the sleeve line (near the shoulder), thus not warranting a penalty under current rules. The collision between Havertz and Khusanov was judged as a normal contesting contact, not a foul preventing a clear scoring opportunity.
Putting the controversies aside, Man City secured a dramatic 2-1 victory. Rayan Cherki opened the scoring for the hosts before Kai Havertz capitalized on goalkeeper Gianluigi Donnarumma's error to equalize. However, Haaland shone brightly with the decisive goal, securing three crucial points for the Blues.
With this result, Man City now trails league leaders Arsenal by exactly three points but still has one match in hand. This victory not only reaffirmed the reigning champion's resilience but also directly altered the landscape of this season's Premier League title race.